By visiting our site, you agree to our privacy policy regarding cookies, tracking statistics, etc. Read more

Sign in
  • HOME
  • WEDWEBCHAT
  • BUSINESS
    • Profiles
    • Trends
  • LIFESTYLE
    • Arts
    • Cars
    • Dining
    • Recipes
    • Spirit Guide
    • Stuff
    • The Long Weekend (Travel)
    • Travel
    • Whip It UP
  • EVENTS
    • BrainStorm
    • Charger Award
    • Future Of MacRitchie
    • JOBS20XX
    • Keep It Going
    • Others
  • CONTACT
    • About STORM – ASIA
Sign in
Welcome!Log into your account
Forgot your password?
Privacy
Password recovery
Recover your password
Search
STORM-ASIA
  • HOME
  • WEDWEBCHAT
    • wwc 040522
      BUSINESS

      Future Leaders Should Not Have A Closed Mind

      wwc 200422 metaverse
      BUSINESS

      Who’s Playing In The Metaverse? — WED WEB CHAT

      wwc a full life
      BUSINESS

      The Ageing Cloud And The Silver Lining

      wwc 060422 full life
      FEATURED

      Are You Living A Full Life?

      WED WEB CHAT MBSAT
      BUSINESS

      Making Good Mindful Decisions

  • BUSINESS
    • AllProfilesTrends
      wwc 040522
      BUSINESS

      Future Leaders Should Not Have A Closed Mind

      Rafael Sweary, WalkMe
      BUSINESS

      WalkMe Guides You Through The Tech

      BUSINESS

      Feeding The Starved Customer

      wwc 200422 metaverse
      BUSINESS

      Who’s Playing In The Metaverse? — WED WEB CHAT

  • LIFESTYLE
    • AllArtsCarsDiningRecipesSpirit GuideStuffThe Long Weekend (Travel)TravelWhip It UP
      BUSINESS

      Feeding The Starved Customer

      Cars

      Lots Of Intelligence And Enthusiasm In The BMW iX

      online shopping
      BUSINESS

      Online Shopping Is Here To Stay

      Audi Q5 Sportback
      Cars

      Audi Q5 Sportback — Nicer On The Inside

  • EVENTS
    • AllBrainStormCharger AwardFuture Of MacRitchieJOBS20XXKeep It GoingOthers
      WED WEB CHAT esports
      BUSINESS

      Esports — Playing To Win

      wwc 281020
      BUSINESS

      Are You Ready To Work For Yourself?

      wwc unconventional jobs
      BUSINESS

      They Dared To Be Different

      wwc071020
      BUSINESS

      Skills To Guide You Out Of COVID-19 — WED WEB CHAT…

  • CONTACT
    • About STORM – ASIA
Home FEATURED Why Does Malaysia’s EPF Pay A Better Return Than The CPF?

Why Does Malaysia’s EPF Pay A Better Return Than The CPF?

By
Thusitha de Silva
-
15/02/2018
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
Linkedin
Email

     

    MALAYSIA’S Employees Provident Fund (EPF) paid a 6.9% dividend for 2017 recently.

    That immediately refocused attention on the 2.5% that is typically doled out by the Singapore Central Provident Fund (CPF) Ordinary Account.

    And Malaysia’s higher rate is not a one-off, as the EPF rate has consistently been higher than the CPF rate over the years.

    Different Investment Approaches

    The difference in returns can be attributed to how money is managed. The CPF invests in Special Singapore Government Securities (SSGS) that are issued and guaranteed by the government. GIC Pte Ltd, along with the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS), manages the proceeds from these investments. SSGS are considered risk-free assets because they are backed by the government.

    In contrast, EPF acts like a typical pension fund and looks to invest both locally and overseas. Monthly contributions from members are invested in a number of approved financial instruments to generate income. They include Malaysian government securities, money market instruments, loans and bonds, equity and property.

    For instance, according to EPF CEO Datuk Shahril Ridza Rdizuan, overseas investments contributed to 41.4% of EPF’s total income in 2017 despite accounting for only 28% of total investments last year.

    In fact, EPF had a presence in 30 markets last year, primarily in developed markets, North Asia and ASEAN.

    You can argue that both CPF and EPF’s investment processes are thus transparent. However, in CPF’s case, there is an additional layer that is not transparent and this has been one of its drawbacks. The proceeds from SGSS issuance are pooled with the rest of the government’s funds, such as Singapore Government Securities (SGS) issuance, government surpluses and well as receipts of land sales.

     


    Volkswagen Fleet


     

    That’s when CPF members lose track of their funds. Due to this commingling of funds there is little or no transparency as to how funds that are attributed to the CPF are invested. It is the way that Singapore has been doing things for a long time and attempts to question this method have always been stopped dead in their tracks.

    Should the CPF act more like a pension fund and less than a source of funds for the government’s combined assets for investment? The answer is yes but doing that would cut off an easy source of funds for the government.


    You Might Also Like To Read:

    PlugIt! Makes EV Charging Infrastructure Accessible

    The Long And Short Of Azimuth Watches


    More Bang For The CPF Buck

    The government has yet to really convince people why they should keep their money locked up in an Ordinary Account that pays a 2.5% return, when members can possibly achieve better returns if they managed their money on their own.

    This has inevitably led to constant calls for more bang for the buck with CPF monies, and it is something that may intensify as aging dynamics take root in Singapore amid a very low total fertility rate.

    One of the big issues with the way the CPF is set up today is that it tries to be too much, or do too much, for too many people. Rules and regulations are constantly tweaked, and the goalposts are moved sporadically in terms of minimum sums and retirement ages.


    For More Commentaries visit http://www.storm.sg/views/


    One Nominated Member of Parliament (NMP) also had the temerity to say a few years back that the CPF may not even be the people’s money. “We have heard proponents who argue that the CPF monies is theirs. ‘It’s our money, it’s in our account, it’s our retirement money. I want it out, I will spend it anyway we want.’ Fine. Is it our money? Our CPF savings are enhanced and forced CPF savings which are accumulated through our own deferred consumption, through co-payment by our employers and through top-ups from public funds. Is it really my private money? Do I have the right to spend it the way I would spend my own salary? I’m not entirely sure,” said NMP Chia Yong Yong during the Budget debate in March 2015.

    Internal Investment Teams

    It is this type of thinking that keeps the pressure on the government about the CPF. Perhaps a solution would be to let the CPF operate more like EPF and have its own internal investment teams. It will then have more flexibility in investing the monthly contributions of its members.

    While this will not be risk-free investment, a return based on performance in any given year will be far more favourably received by CPF members.

    A decent financial literacy rate in Singapore means that people understand that there are risks associated with investing. Investing in risk-free instruments is akin to putting money in bank deposits. This is no longer how people around the world build their retirement nest eggs.

    Indeed, creating internal investment teams for CPF should have been done many years ago, but it inexplicably hasn’t. The government should not always seek to protect CPF members from the vagaries of global markets, if that is its intention. Investing in risk-free instruments is not an efficient use of CPF monies. It has an opportunity cost as the return differentials between the EPF and CPF have shown over the years.


    Thus It Was Unboxed by One-Five-Four Analytics presents alternative angles to current events. Reach us at 154analytics@gmail.com


    See also  Survival Of Singapore's Night Scene
    • Zoho One
    Previous article7 Danger Signals About Your Digital Valentine
    Next articleThe Long-Table Lo-Hei Toss
    Thusitha de Silva

    RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

    BMW
    FEATURED

    Another BMW Dealer Good For Customers?

    Mentoring WED WEB CHAT
    FEATURED

    The Business Of Show Business

    Egyptology Jordan Miller
    FEATURED

    Why Would A Singaporean Study Egyptology?

    • Azimuth Lava
    • OUE
    • Turmeron 700 ad

    Latest Articles

    BMW

    Another BMW Dealer Good For Customers?

    23/05/2022
    Mentoring WED WEB CHAT

    The Business Of Show Business

    19/05/2022
    Egyptology Jordan Miller

    Why Would A Singaporean Study Egyptology?

    17/05/2022
    Lost Illusions

    Joy And Sorrow At The European Film Festival

    12/05/2022
    skoda octavia RS

    Czech Mate On The Road

    09/05/2022

    Tag Clouds

    Ai (28) artificial intelligence (27) audi (27) BMW (40) business (71) cars (28) chicken (27) china (71) Chinese New Year (29) Circuit breaker (40) Covid-19 (140) discussion (45) donald trump (27) easy recipes (114) education (25) facebook (25) food (105) google (26) India (27) kannan chandran (33) keep it going (73) ku swee yong (39) luxury (48) luxury cars (26) malaysia (31) nanyang business school (25) ntu (27) oue (51) pandemic (88) recipe (90) seafood (28) singapore (160) social media (25) storm magazine (40) stormsasia (32) storm sg (59) SUV (46) technology (48) the Nth revolutioN (29) travel (30) Vault@268 (38) w. atelier (26) WED WEB CHAT (45) wedwebchat (53) whip it up! (142)
    • | About
    • | Advertise with us
    • | Contact
    • | Privacy Policy
    • | Terms & Conditions
    © 2021 - Published by E-Quill Media Pte Ltd | Powered by Axon Consulting
    MORE STORIES
    BMW

    Another BMW Dealer Good For Customers?

    23/05/2022
    Mentoring WED WEB CHAT

    The Business Of Show Business

    19/05/2022
    Egyptology Jordan Miller

    Why Would A Singaporean Study Egyptology?

    17/05/2022